I don't mean to pat myself on the back for this one, but I called this whole episode. I'm pretty proud of myself too because it took me forever before I figured out the big twist in The Sixth Sense. Pretty slow on the uptake with that one, but credits were pretty much still rolling when I figured this one out. The good thing about this show is that even when it gets predictable, it throws in a curve ball. This is why I love this show.
We open with dear sweet Libby and Hurley doing some exercising on the beach. Not that kind of exercising , get your mind out of the gutter. Really exercising like running on sand. I don't know how you all feel about running on sand but it's sorta like pushing a rock uphill for me. And don't even think about getting me to play any beach volleyball. I can only jump about half an inch. Libby tries to encourage him, but he admits that it's not really the exercise part that's his problem. I mean, it sorta is, but we know what he means. She doesn't really understand what he means. They're on a deserted island, with rationed food, what could possibly be the problem.
He takes her to his problem. I like to call it, his stash. Since he was in charge of the food, Lord only knows why, he slowly took whatever he wanted and stored it all in the jungle, macaroni and cheese, cereal, peanut butter. It takes a lot for him to tell her this. He says he wants to get rid of it but can't. She, like any skinny bitch, tells him to just get rid of it. He finally understands what she's saying, because as someone who loves food, especially food that I will never see again because I'm on a deserted island, it took me minute too. She means he should throw it away. In the worst scene since those bastards dropped the blood on Carrie at the prom, Hurley starts ripping up and wasting all of this food. I understand his desire to get the temptation away, but they're on an island, they were starving before they found that hatch, and he's ripping up and ruining all of this perfectly good food because he's fat. I'm sorry you don't have the will power, trust me, I get it, but to waste all of that food is just frakin' stupid. If he's strong enough to ruin it he should be strong enough to go give it away now. They have a good time ensuring their deaths come sooner and have a moment that looks like they're going to kiss.
Sadly it doesn't happen because all of the sudden the other castaways start running by, toward something. When Libby and Hurley follow them they see the dropped food from the last episode. The other castaways are freaking out, gathering as much as they can. Libby and Hurley are dismayed. They should be happy, here's more food to waste so Hurley can get over being fat. They wonder where the food came from and Charlie gets them up to date about the hatch doors coming down with Locke inside. They didn't really ask all that, but I guess Charlie wants them to get the entire picture. Charlie wonders if anyone saw the plane. Forget about seeing it, did anyone hear it? No one did and Sawyer makes some cute comment that reminds me of how much I want to just eat him up. Everyone starts to get a little too excited about the food and mini-fights start breaking out. Charlie thinks they should have someone watch the food again. Someone who they can trust not to take any, someone like Hurley. Hurley's not too happy with this idea so Libby steps in and suggests everyone just take what they need. Does she mean what they need for a week? For a year? Sawyer doesn't think this is a good idea.
Hurley's too dazed to argue because behind the crowd of people he sees that bald guy Charlotte married from
Sex and The City. He's wearing a bathrobe and gives Hurley a half smile. Hurley goes over to where he was and he's not there, he's closer to the edge of the woods. Hurely follows him as Libby looks on, concerned. As Hurley starts running I wonder if maybe that's what they need to do, it's like a carrot. He'd run if he has a purpose. Maybe not though because after a few seconds he trips and falls on his face. It's dangerous to run through the jungle. Alas, this may not have been one of those hallucinations, ala the horse and Jack's father, this could be real because Hurley does find one of the guy's slippers on the ground. He then goes around the entire camp seeing whose foot fits into it.
I hope he was using Odor EatersOn the beach later Hurley's staring at the slipper. Libby comes up and he hurries and hides it. She asks him if he's okay and why he took off running in the first place. He plays it off and doesn't really give her a solid answer. She then starts getting all island conspiracy on us and thinks the island doesn't want Hurley to lose weight. Does the island like popcorn and sad movies too? Libby says she's proud of him for not freaking out. I guess running into the woods after someone who isn't there may not be freaking out in her book.
In the first flashback of the night Hurley's in a shrink's office. The shrink is played by the charming and wonderful Bruce Davison. He wonders how Hurley’s diet is going. I don't know Dr. Bruce, how does it look like it's going? Not very well. Dr. Bruce promises it'll get better. They talk a bit about Hurley’s mother, and how her visit went. We find out that she's the one who put him in here, after some sort of "accident". It's been nearly two month he's been in the hospital and Dr. Bruce is looking for some results. Two months... interesting. Dr. Bruce has given Hurley homework, of which he hasn't done. His dog ate it. He's pissed because no one else had homework. Who else is he talking about Dr. Bruce wonders. Dave, his friend, who said he didn't do it either because it's stupid. At this moment I figure out what's going on. I'll tell you a little more and see when you figure it out. Dr. Bruce warns that Dave can be a negative influence, and that Dave doesn't want him to change. Hurley thinks Dave's the most normal person in there.
This psychiatric hospital is pretty nice. They have a gym and all. There's a friendly game of basketball going on, and look, there's
Sex and The City baldy, he's Dave. The guys on his team won't pass him the ball, but what do they know, they're all crazy. Dave sees Hurley and goes over, at which point one of the basketball guys finally throws the ball, although it's just to Hurley. Dave gets pissed, since Hurley isn't even in the game. Dave wants to go have some dinner but Hurley tells him that Dr. Bruce said he was a bad influence. No he's not, but while they're on the subject, it's Taco night, and they better get there soon because crazy Helen's building a Taco house and they'll run out soon.
That's some bedside manner I wouldn't mindBack on the island, in the hatch, Jack's finally looking over Locke's wounded leg. Locke can wiggle his toes and asks Jack if it's broken. Since Jack shipped his X-ray glasses back to America on a Fed Ex cargo plane, he can't tell. If he has to guess, which he does, yes, there's probably a small fracture. He thinks Locke won't be able to walk on it for a few weeks. When he suggests that wheelchair on the beach Locke freaks out. Whoa, whoa, okay, no wheelchair. And even if he did have a wheelchair, how the hell is he supposed to get around. If I can't jump in the sand I sure as hell wouldn't be able to push myself around in a wheelchair. Kate thinks crutches will do and goes off to get them. Since Henry didn't leave Locke the night before when the hatch opened, and he was wounded, Locke tries to talk Jack into not hating the guy. Jack rightfully points out that Henry thought his story was going to check out, so he didn't need to leave.
"Potatoes, spaghetti sauce, toilet paper..."Speaking of Henry, they've strung him up in the locker by his wrists and Sayid is questioning him. Sayid should feel fairly vindicated since he was sure the guy was an Other from the very beginning. He questions the man about the real Henry Gale. Henry (I'll just call him still because it'd get too confusing if I called him anything else) says that the real Henry Gale was already dead when he found him. Henry says that four months before he was part of a search party, and that they found Gale, his neck already broken. Ana-Lucia walks in and hears Henry finish the story, that he was nice enough to bury the man and put up a marker. You know, in case someone took him hostage in the future and he needed an alias. (Speaking of
Alias, the show returns for the final episodes of the series starts Wednesday, April 19that 8pm!!!) Sayid finds this story amusing, and pulls out a twenty dollar bill. Looks like writing on it. Sure enough, Sayid tells Henry that Gale wrote his last thoughts on the bill. Uh oh. It's a goodbye letter to a "Jennifer" about crossing the Pacific and owing her a beer. It then says that he's going to the beach to start a signal fire. Then of course the normal, "if you're reading this..." sign off. Sayid wants to know how Henry knew Gale's wife's name. Did he interrogate him? Oh, good question. Henry starts to get nervous and Sayid starts getting angrier, asking how many of them are there. Henry says "you have no idea what he'll do" to him if he told. Sayid wants to know who this person is and Ana-Lucia wonders if it's the guy with the beard. Henry says that he's no one. Sayid whips out a gun and points it at Henry's head, saying he has 3 seconds to tell him how many there are. He counts and Henry's screaming and when he gets to three he actually pulls the trigger. Luckily Ana-Lucia steps in at the last minute and pushes his arm up, making him shoot the wall. I'm sure Henry's crapped his pants by now.
Since Locke can't move he starts yelling that he heard a gunshot and Jack runs to the locker. Ana-Lucia has the gun and encourages Jack to get Sayid out of there. Poor Locke is still yelling from his bed, helpless. Jack finally goes over to him and tells him that he has it covered. What covered? Has someone been shot? Jack could have definitely told him a little something more, like "everything's alright". Henry tries to thank Ana-Lucia and she just leaves the locker and closes the door behind her.
Near the beach Charlie pulls some sort of pallet to Eko who's sawing some wood. He tells him that he thinks maybe he could use this wood for whatever it is he's building. I think this is more of him being nosy then helpful, but Eko's not biting, he doesn't say what he's building, just asks Charlie if he wants to help. There's nothing else better to do so Charlie agrees. As they're working Charlie again tries to get out of him what the hell he's building but he won't say, at least not yet. He's so mysterious.
In the jungle Hurley's searching around for Dave with the guy's one slipper. He comes across where the food drop was. Unfortunately, someone left a box of "Fish Crackers" which I can only assume are Dharma's version of "Goldfish". I guess in this situation even I'd eat those nasty things. Hurley starts devouring them and voila, Dave appears. Hurley closes his eyes and insists Dave's not there. He picks up what looks like a rock and throws it at Hurley. That bastard. Hurley just looks at him and he picks it up again. I think it may just be a coconut. Before he can throw it he runs off into the jungle. Hurley runs after him and comes through the jungle right in front of Charlie and Eko. I think it startles them for more then one reason but most of all because it seems Hurley's just been running. Hurley wants to know if they just saw a guy in a bathrobe just run by. Eko says that he didn't and Charlie makes some smart ass comment about a polar bear. Hurley plays it off and walks away.
In the institution Hurley's playing Connect 4 with Leonard. Remember Leonard's the guy that got Hurley in trouble with those damn numbers. He's still muttering them but Hurley's not yet sick of it. Dave thinks these are "magic numbers" and funny enough, Dave's sorta right. Hurley thinks they're just numbers. Give it a year or so buddy. Dave sees some celery near Hurley and wonders what the hell it is. It's a vegetable that's great dipped in bloody marys. Regardless, Dave doesn't think it's a snack. I'm there with ya there Dave. He sees Leonard has some graham crackers. Yeah, I guess that's better then celery. Dave wants Hurley to steal some off of Leonard's plate, he'll never notice. Man, this Dave guy's an a**hole. When the nurse comes around with Hurley's medication Dave tells him not to take it, that if he ever wants to get out of there he shouldn't take the horse tranquilizer. I think the kids call it "Special K". Anyway, Hurley starts to talk about Dr. Bruce and Dave interrupts him, saying Dr. Bruce doesn't care about him. We find out that one of the pills Hurley's taking is called Clonazepam. We'll need to know this for a future scene. Just then Dr. Bruce shows up and wonders if everything's okay. Yeah, he was just talking to Dave. Dr. Bruce says hi to Dave and Dave looks disgusted. Dr. Bruce has a camera and wants to take a picture of the two of them. (Okay, if you haven't figured it out yet that Dave's an imaginary friend and how this picture's going to come into play then maybe LOST isn't the right show for you) Hurley puts his arm around Dave and Dr. Bruce takes the picture. He asks Hurley if he's taken the meds and Hurley dutifully takes them and Dr. Bruce walks off. Dave's excited when he realizes Hurley didn't take the pills after all.
Back on the island Sawyer's eating Dharma's version of Oreo cookies. I'm trying to figure out if all this Dharma food would be better or worse then the regular kind. Let's hope it'd be better, with lots of vitamins and minerals. Anyway, he tries to do the whole taking off the top and eating it thing but it just breaks. Hurley walks up and tells him the right technique, to twist it first. Sawyer then throws the uneaten cookie on the ground. What is it with these people and wasting food? He'll never have that again. It's not like he can go down to store and buy another bag, he'll have to wait until the mysterious plane drops it from the frakin' sky. Sorry, I just hate wasting food. Sawyer says that he has enough food to open a mini mart and wonders if Sayid needs a job. Okay that's fraked up, but sorta funny. Hurley's not there for Oreo education though, he wants to see if Sawyer has that medication he was taking in the hospital. Sawyer wonders why he needs it and Hurley gives him a quick rundown of Dave, without coming out and saying that he knows his name and has been seeing him for years. Sawyer asks if he means that guy over there and Hurley quickly turns around. That silly Sawyer, there's no one there. Hurley freaks out and attacks Sawyer. They fall into Sawyer's tent and it collapses on them. Sawyer tries to crawl out, yell for help, but Hurley pulls him back under. Jin and Sun and a few others hurry over. When they realize it's Sawyer getting his ass kicked they don't do anything. Sun finally tells Jin to break them up and he does.
Kate's on the beach retrieving the crutches when she hears the commotion. She goes over to Sawyer who looks a little bit banged up and laughs but says she's concerned. He basically tells her to go away and she wonders why it is Hurley would attack him, I mean besides all the other reasons, the guns, the drugs, the redneck attidude, etc. Sawyer just repeats that he thinks he's crazy.
Poor Hurley's packing to leave the beach. Libby finds him and wants to know what the hell happened with Sawyer and how it felt to hit the sumabitch. She sees that he puts a large Dharma peanut butter into his backpack. She wants to help him but really doesn't know what to do. She questions the whole peanut butter thing but truly, does somewhere really need an excuse to eat and love peanut butter, I think not. Hurley plays it off that he's going to need protein because he's going to go back to the caves and become a hermit. She tries to help him but he insists she can't.
As he's walking through the jungle his backpack rips and the peanut butter falls out. It breaks on a rock and it's the creamy kind. I'm not a fan of creamy, although it's great for just smothering it on some ice cream and heating up. I wonder if that plane dropped any ice cream. Anyway, he picks up a huge gob of it with a leaf and starts eating. Suddenly Dave appears again and Hurley tries to pretend he's not there. Hurley thinks Dave can't be there because he's still at the hospital. Dave insists that yes, he is there.
We're back at the hospital and Hurley's with Dr. Bruce. His dog didn't eat his homework this time. Hurley goes over what seems to be what he likes about himself. One of the things is that he likes chicken. When Dr. Bruce corrects him he says that he likes that he likes chicken. Oh Hurley. Dr. Bruce wonders why he didn't say anything about the way he looks. Hurley thinks that he can't do anything about it anyway so whateva. Dr. Bruce pries him a bit and it comes out that Hurley thinks that if he wasn't so fat then what happen (I'm assuming the "accident" he was talking about earlier) wouldn't have happened, that they wouldn't have died. Interesting. Basically it was sorta like that episode of ER last year. There were too many people on a deck and Hurley stepped out. Straw that broke the camel's back sorta thing. Hurley obviously just feels guilty, and that after the accident he stopped talking and going out and sleeping, but he didn't stop eating, since that's how he punishes himself. Hurley then gets upset and tells Dr. Bruce that Dave was right about him, and that Dave cares about him, is his friend. Dr. Bruce then shows Hurley the picture he took of him and Dave and guess what, there's no Dave, just Hurley sitting there with his arm around no one.
In Hurley's room that night Dave comes by to break out. Hurley's a bit confused, since he now realizes Dave's a figment of his imagination. Dave slaps him to make him realizes this is real. I'm thinking this might turn into that awesome Fight Club scene where he's kicking his own ass. Dave does slap him again and Hurley tells him about the picture, and him not being in it. Dave tries to play it off and says that Dr. Bruce used Photoshop to doctor it. Hurley kinda accepts this and they go down a corridor. Dave points out a tray of food which Hurley quickly grabs and starts eating off of. They go past a guard and make it to a locked window. Dave wants to know if Hurley has those keys he stole off of Dr. Bruce's desk. He reaches into his pocket and there they are, very Fight Club. They open the window and Dave's exhilarated, even jumps out. Hurley's still unsure of this whole thing and stays inside. He comes to the conclusion, after Dave goes on and on about the great food they're going to have, that maybe Dave doesn't want him to get better after all. Dave says that if he doesn't come with him now, that he'll never get out of there. Hurley takes a moment to think about it and then closes the window on Dave.
Back on the island Hurley has his eyes closed real tight and when he opens them, guess what, Dave's still there. Dave asks for his slipper back and Hurley gives it to him. Dave sits down next to him and warns him that things are going to get worse before they can get better. What's worse then being trapped on an island with the Others and a crazy French women? Not being there. What you say? Well, after Hurley tells Dave about after leaving him outside and Dr. Bruce letting him out and going back to live with his mom and getting that great job at Mr. Clucks, Dave drops a damn big bomb. He says that none of that ever happened, that he's still in the hospital. Hurley doesn't really understand what he's saying, but if you've ever seen that dumbass movie
Vanilla Sky, you'll know what he's talking about. He says that the island and everything that's happened is all in his head, that he's in some sort of coma and it's all imagined. Hurley starts believing it when Dave wonders what numbers he played to win the lottery, oh, Leonard's number, the ones that are popping up all over the island too. This must mean he's in a coma and dreaming everything. Then he takes it where no friend should ever take it. He talks about Libby. He says that in the real world no cute blonde chick would ever just appear and have the hots for him. I can't really argue with that one.
As Dave walks Hurley through the jungle they talk about everything being in his head and that Dave represents the part of him that wants him to wake up. They get to high cliff and oh look, it's Tom Cruise and Kurt Russell there. To snap out of this coma he says to throw himself off of the cliff. He has to tell his mind that he doesn't believe in all of this and that Neo and Trinity will be there for him when he wakes up. To prove that this isn't dangerous, Hurley's imaginary friend jumps off the cliff.
In the hatch Locke approaches the locker and Ana-Lucia who's taking apart a gun and timing herself with a blindfold on. Locke asks about Jack who's on the beach telling everyone they caught an Other. Locke wants to talk to Henry but Ana-Lucia doesn't think that's the best idea. He asks or five minutes and she agrees. Locke goes in and Henry's resigned to just be creepy. He talks about God not being around for them and Locke thinks maybe his "people" are looking for him. Henry thinks the hatch is a joke. He says that he crawled through the vents and stood at the computer as the alarms beeped and just let the counter go down. He says it flipped through some hieroglyphics. Then he says that he heard a loud sound that sounded like a magnet. What the hell does a magnet sound like? He asks Locke if he knows what happened next and of course he doesn't, he had a door in his leg. Nothing. He says the timer went back and started counting down. In case we didn't get what he just said, he says he never pushed the button. Locke thinks he's lying but Henry says that he's done lying. Locke just gets frustrated.
On the cliff Hurley's calling after Dave when Libby shows up. She wants to know who the hell Dave is and Hurley wants to know how she knew he was up there. She says that eagle eye'd Jin saw him while he was fishing. Trying to catch her in a lie he says that Jin doesn't speak English. Sun was there to translate. Ha. Hurley starts spouting craziness about her being the part of him that's scared and doesn't want to wake up. He's backing up towards the edge and Libby says that she understands he's having a little panic attack. She's confused because it's not like him but he's on the defensive and wonders how she even knows him. Libby says that she was starting to get to know him and bats her eyelashes a bit. He admits that he killed two people because he's fat and that he has an imaginary friend who's a douche bag. Libby's afraid he's going to hurt himself. And by hurt himself she means fall off the cliff and shatter into a million bloody pieces. He reassures her that he's not because he's imagining all of this. He goes with what Dave was saying that no girl like her would ever like him. He puts it together about how at the beginning he said he thought he knew her from somewhere, he says its because he made it up. Then Libby asks him what the name is of the man who broke his leg was when they first got there, on the other side of the island. Of course he doesn't know what his name was. Libby knows because she buried him. She says that he couldn't have made that up because she remembers doing all of that stuff and it was real to her. As she's talking he's thinking about it and asks her if she saw him holding a slipper earlier on the beach. She says no. She then holds Hurley's face in her hands and says that she's real and that the way she feels about him is real. Then she kisses him. He asks her to kiss him again and she does. She successfully has talked him off of the ledge.
In the bad ass moment of the night (still a bit predictable, but I'll go with it) it's a flashback to the scene where Dr. Bruce was taking a picture of Hurley and Dave's not there. As we pull back there's someone sitting at another table. Sure enough, it's Libby, with dark hair, staring off into space, probably on "Special K" too.